时间:2025-03-18 01:28:57 来源:网络整理编辑:知識
Casually lobbed by Donald Trump in early August after falling behind in the polls, allegations of vo
Casually lobbed by Donald Trump in early August after falling behind in the polls, allegations of vote-rigging in the U.S. elections have gone from political fringes to a mainstream battering ram of the right.
The concerns—largely dismissed as unreasonable by reputable voting groups—are being amplified in the favored arena of this campaign: Twitter.
SEE ALSO:Too late, this election has already been hackedHundreds of thousands of allegations of vote rigging in the U.S. elections are being made on Twitter, and they're being fueled by three distinct groups, according to an analysis by the think-tank Demosfor Mashable.
"It's far easier to make a claim on social media than it is to rebut it," says Carl Miller, Research Director at Demos.
"Platforms like Twitter allow fears and concerns, of dead people voting, of ballot boxes being stuffed -- whatever the facts -- to spread faster and further than ever before," Miller continued.
Tweet may have been deleted
Over a two-week period from Oct. 19 to Nov. 2, 3.8 million tweets were analysed. In those tweets, there were over 600,000 allegations of vote rigging, made by 112,000 Twitter users.
Researchers from the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media based at the University of Sussex collected tweets with hashtags identified as, at least in part, devoted to discussing the legitimacy of the US presidential elections.
The hashtags selected for the analysis were:
#draintheswamp
#riggedelection
#stophillary2016
#crookedhillary
#neverhillary
#voterfraud
#riggedelections
#hillaryforprison2016
#rigged2016
#mediarigged
#pollsrigged
Then, using a natural language processing algorithm, researchers identified relevant tweets that made a genuine allegation of vote rigging.
The data only contain meaningful and relevant allegations of vote rigging, while tweets simply calling a candidate corrupt or flawed, for example, were discarded. Negative comments about the general state of the political system weren't included unless they went on to claim the election itself was rigged. Only specific tweets of people claiming they'd been deprived of the democratic process were considered.
Using the data, it's possible to paint a picture of what groups, specifically, are repeatedly claiming the election is rigged.
The image below shows everyone who's made ten separate tweets claiming the election is rigged. Clustered together are people who constantly tweet and retweet each other.
Demos has named the groups: Trump and the Gang, Conspiracy Hunters, and Conservative Cheerleaders.
This is Trump's core group. In the centre is the Donald himself, surrounded by people who constantly praise him all the time and broader campaign supporters saying the election's rigged, based on what Trump has said. Profiles include the Once Upon a Time in Americastar James Woods.
These are people who spread conspiracy theories about everything—they're not necessarily out-and-out Trump supporters. Accounts include Infowars pundit Alex Jones and James O'Keefe of Project Veritas.
Conservative Cheerleaders are Evangelicals and Republican accounts who are public figures, not necessarily conspiracy theorists or outright Trump supporters. Demos found that 38 percent of the total users showed explicit support for Trump in their profile -- many are self-described 'deplorables'.
A classifier trained to recognise explicit support for Trump (it operated at around 80% accuracy) showed 220,381 of the 576,833 tweets analysed were sent from people with explicit support in their profile.
The data also show concerns about vote rigging as steadily building, and that breaking news events informed that conversation, leading to spikes in the number of allegations of rigging being made on Twitter.
Only a third of Republicans say they have a great deal or quite a bit of confidence that votes will be counted fairly, according to the Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research.
And yet, a total of only 31 known cases of impersonation fraud have been found in one billion votes cast in all US elections between 2000 and 2014, according to Justin Levitt, a professor at Loyola Law School.
The graph below shows a surge in vote rigging claims on Twitter on Oct. 18 when the second video was released by James O'Keefe from Project Veritas claiming that the DNC and Hillary Clinton committed voter fraud on a massive scale.
The second example below -- highlighted in a red box -- happened when Donald Trump responded to comments made by the filmmaker Michael Moore following the release of his documentary Trumpland. At its highest, there were 5,500 tweets sent in an hour.
From the research, it emerged that there's a hardcore group of Trump supporters -- 7.5 percent -- who tweeted about electoral fraud every single day. Half of the total amount of users only joined the conversation once.
One user tweeted nearly 4,000 times over two weeks -- but turned out to be an electoral bot. That's not surprising if one considers research from Oxford University that revealed more than a third of pro-Trump tweets and nearly a fifth of pro-Clinton tweets came from automated accounts between the first and the second presidential debate.
Over a half of the people who tweeted about rigged elections have 500 followers or less, indicating perhaps grassroots support for Trump.
That figure begins to shift as the number of followers go between 1,000 to 5,000 followers -- which gathers 27% of the unique users.
The users' location can also give some interesting insights. Predictably, there's a higher concentration of tweets in urban areas (where there are higher concentrations of people, and thus, social media users).
California -- the tech and social media heart of the country and home to Silicon Valley -- and its enormous population had the highest number of tweets about rigged elections. This more likely reflects the high adoption of Twitter in those places, and not necessarily pockets of high skepticism of the electoral process.
In some states -- Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania and Iowa -- there's more activity than state populations would suggest, according to Miller of Demos.
Any path Trump might take to win the presidency leads through those places, which he once described as "rusting and rotting" zones of manufacturing decline.
The research was conducted over a fortnight by the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media (CASM), a think-tank unit dedicated to researching digital society. CASM is a collaboration between Demos and the Text Analytics Group (Tag Laboratory) at the University of Sussex.
Mashablewill release a second analysis of rigging complaints on Twitter after the election.
TopicsDonald Trump
This German startup wants to be your bank (without being a bank)2025-03-18 01:26
內馬爾:未來想去美職聯 希望國家隊進球數超貝利2025-03-18 01:24
“體教融合”再結碩果 上海申花&楓葉國際學校戰略合作簽約2025-03-18 01:09
巴黎要求姆巴佩3月15日作出決定 若不續約就冷藏?2025-03-18 01:08
Balloon fanatic Tim Kaine is also, of course, very good at harmonica2025-03-18 00:41
曝波蘭超級聯賽前鋒無緣加盟亞泰 因未在規定時間內簽約2025-03-18 00:36
十佳球:蘇亞雷斯吊射 馬內倒勾+斯特林弧線球破門2025-03-18 00:07
切爾西前瞻 :捍衛不敗主場 圖赫爾點明對手大變樣2025-03-17 23:55
Pokémon Go is so big that it has its own VR porn parody now2025-03-17 23:20
韓喬生:國足已提前告別世界杯 後麵應多給年輕小將機會2025-03-17 23:04
5 people Tim Cook calls for advice on running the biggest company in the world2025-03-18 01:28
泰山隊國腳暫不參加球隊冬訓 外援預計在3月份陸續歸隊2025-03-18 01:16
奧斯卡已歸隊海港集中開啟冬訓 補強或從鋒線下手2025-03-18 01:05
周最佳 :凱恩摧垮曼城奪MVP 羅伊斯造5球僅列替補2025-03-18 00:36
This German startup wants to be your bank (without being a bank)2025-03-18 00:12
22日賠率:尤文客場戰平黃潛 切爾西主場輕取裏爾2025-03-18 00:10
國足三月初海口集訓一周 遴選出不到30人西征名單2025-03-17 23:59
熱議國足集訓名單:唯一看點是非血緣歸化能否歸隊 應早點更新換代2025-03-17 23:40
Make money or go to Stanford? Katie Ledecky is left with an unfair choice.2025-03-17 23:05
萊萬真去皇馬?續約談判停滯 格納布裏加薪也難產2025-03-17 23:01