您的当前位置:首页 >百科 >【】That's not the case this time. 正文
时间:2024-09-20 09:22:18 来源:网络整理编辑:百科
UPDATED Nov. 1, 2017 at 5:45 p.m. PT with a statement from Christopher Clack.。In a rare move that is
UPDATED Nov. 1, 2017 at 5:45 p.m. PT with a statement from Christopher Clack.。
In a rare move that is likely to spark an intense debate in the climate science community, Mark Z. Jacobson, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Stanford University, has filed suit in D.C. Superior Court against the author and publisher of a peer reviewed study criticizing his work.。
Jacobson is the lead author of a widely publicized study in the 。 Jacobson is the lead author of a widely publicized study in the 。 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences。
(PNAS) in 2015 that mapped out a course to powering the U.S. entirely by renewable energy sources by the year 2050.。
That paper was followed in 2017 by a study authored by Christopher Clack, of Vibrant Energy, a grid modeling company, along with 20 coauthors. That study found serious flaws in Jacobson's methodology, and it too was published in PNAS. The journal also published a rebuttal by Jacobson and his coauthors refuting Clack's findings.。SEE ALSO:Can the U.S. run only on wind, water, and solar power?
SEE ALSO:Can the U.S. run only on wind, water, and solar power? Scientists disagree. 。
Typically, in climate science or any other scientific field, that would be the end of this story -- scientists tend to argue their ideas via peer reviewed studies and conference panels, not through the courts. 。
That's not the case this time.。
The suit, filed on Sept. 29, seeks $10 million in damages for "libel and slander" from Clack and the National Academy of Sciences (NAS), which publishes the journal in which both studies appeared. 。
Mashable Light SpeedWant more out-of-this world tech, space and science stories?Sign up for Mashable's weekly Light Speed newsletter.。
By signing up you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.。
Thanks for signing up!。
The suit states that in publishing the study critical of Jacobson's work, the NAS violated its own publication standards. The suit also lays out the case that the Clack study harmed Jacobson's career by alleging that he and his coauthors at Stanford had committed basic computer modeling errors. 。
"Baseless allegations of modeling errors can be found throughout the Clack article," the lawsuit states. "These allegations are relevant and particularly damaging to Dr. Jacobson, whose main research work is on the development and application of numerical computer models."。
Tweet may have been deleted 。
Jacobson and his team contend that they did not make modeling errors, but instead included assumptions in their models that they had told Clack about before his study was published. "There were no mathematical or computational errors in any of the underlying models. Rather, Dr. Jacobson and his co-authors made an intentional modeling assumption," which concerned the amount of electricity generated from hydropower.。
Jacobson's suit says the Clack article is continuing to damage his reputation by getting wide media exposure.。
"The resulting headlines and articles in the press made Dr. Jacobson and his co-authors look like poor, sloppy, incompetent, and clueless researchers when, in fact, there were no 'modeling errors' made in their study," the suit states.。 Tweet may have been deleted 。Tweet may have been deleted。
The suit seeks punitive damages from both the NAS and Clack, as well as the Clack paper's retraction.。
Clack called the lawsuit "unfortunate" in a statement to 。
Mashable。 . 。
Mashable 。
One of the most controversial power struggles in media comes to a close2024-09-20 09:06
斯特林完成英超100球裏程碑 5場3球完勝億元格102024-09-20 08:48
名宿:德容像背著50公斤土豆 若去拜仁會完全不同2024-09-20 08:47
巴黎前瞻 :姆巴佩對陣老東家 梅西欲破解尷尬紀錄2024-09-20 08:40
Hiddleswift finally followed each other on Instagram after 3 excruciating days2024-09-20 08:14
拜仁VS美因茨首發:萊萬攜穆勒領銜 穆西亞拉出戰2024-09-20 07:47
滄州雄獅主帥:同組的對手都很有實力 我們已做好準備2024-09-20 07:38
世紀勝場 :C羅596場霸榜 本澤馬超阿爾維斯入三甲2024-09-20 07:25
Whyd voice2024-09-20 07:19
搶分機器 !C羅英超4次打入製勝球 為曼聯搶回7分2024-09-20 06:57
This 'sh*tpost' bot makes terrible memes so you don't have to2024-09-20 09:06
知情人 :如果與廣州隊解約 艾克森阿蘭為國出戰可能性微乎其微2024-09-20 08:56
河北隊總經理:球員們做好自己 俱樂部會努力保障大家權益2024-09-20 08:55
勁旅2100萬鎊報價阿紮爾 皇馬還價:至少得4300萬2024-09-20 08:42
This weird squid looks like it has googly eyes, guys2024-09-20 08:41
李霄鵬首期集訓將補充有潛質新人 無法左右歸化球員去留2024-09-20 08:22
上海申花俱樂部成立28周年:夢在遠方路在腳下 抬起頭再出發2024-09-20 08:12
鄭智:有些歸化球員和俱樂部中止合同了 我們要踢完比賽2024-09-20 07:52
Researchers create temporary tattoos you can use to control your devices2024-09-20 07:05
傑拉德以對手身份重回安菲爾德 賽後直言不服氣2024-09-20 06:57