时间:2025-04-26 17:49:17 来源:网络整理编辑:熱點
People are awful. It’s the obvious (but no less depressing) reality that Facebook—and es
People are awful. It’s the obvious (but no less depressing) reality that Facebook—and especially Mark Zuckerberg—somehow failed to recognize.
Whether it was a naive belief or a negligent assumption, the fact remains: Zuckerberg built Facebook’s content control systems with the core idea that people can police themselves. Now, he's been scrambling for months, if not longer, doubling down crafting rules to herd his trolling-prone cats. Of course, it’s been a dismal failure.
SEE ALSO:Secret Facebook documents reveal how site battles violent contentThe hundreds of pages of Facebook Moderator guidelines uncovered by The Guardianare a stunningly analog solution for a digital company as advanced as Facebook. They're also the clearest indication yet that Facebook's just making this up as they go along.
What’s also clear is how deeply ineffectual these guidelines are—not just for users, but for Facebook’s army of moderators and the two billion Facebook users who rely on them to keep their feeds scrubbed of the most disturbing content.
And that content's disturbing.
Reading through guidelines for Graphic Content, Revenge Porn, Sexual Child Abuse, it's hard not to be struck by Facebook’s plodding attempts to identify what is and isn’t objectionable, as well as the base nature of the examples.
Much of what appears in these stark, black and white slides is drawn, it seems, from Facebook itself. It's a soul-shaking window into the dark, animal heart of humans on the Internet. So many angry and awful impulses—and Facebook's been a home to all of them. In a way, it's easy to feel for Facebook and Mark Zuckerberg. This probably isn’t what he had in mind when he created Facebook. He probably should’ve known better, right?
Thing is, Zuckerberg's the product of a relatively privileged and sheltered upbringing. His recent talking tour of the United States is the best evidence we have of this. For example, this is someone who's just discovering that our relationships have a huge influence, that juvenile detention centers create more criminals than they rehabilitate, and that it’s hard to meet people who might have a positive influence on your life, especially if you stay where you were born. Even if he's learning late, again, better late than never.
Facebook has all the hallmarks of being designed by someone who didn’t understand how their society really works—who couldn’t see that “connecting the world” wasn’t necessarily a positive goal if you didn’t account for the pockets of hate, harm, disassociation, and unrest that define so much of it.
Which makes perfect sense, when you remember that Facebook started as a digital version of the college face book some universities produced to help students get acquainted (my college didn’t have one, but they were popular with Ivy League Universities like Zuckerberg’s Harvard).
A university is an ostensibly diverse place, with a wide range of emotional states across the student body, but there’s also a singularly of purpose—getting a college degree—and usually, more balance on the demographic and socio-economic scale than you might find in an average American city.
It’s easy to connect people who are mostly alike, whose homogeny helps define the kinds of content they share. But outside those Ivy-covered digital walls, things can devolve. Quickly.
In the early days of Facebook, a young Mark Zuckerberg encouraged programmers to "move fast and break things." Even when he adjusted that motto in 2014 to the far less pithy “Move Fast with Stable Infra," it was less about what Facebook was breaking on a societal level, and much more about not breaking the product hundreds of millions of people were already relying on.
Facebook is a very different platform than it was in 2007, or even 2014. The expansion of its sharing tools (most recently live video) and its shift to a mobile-first platform has radically altered its sharing potential. Facebook’s window on the world and its calamities is never closed.
Which is why it’s not entirely surprising that today’s Mark Zuckerberg is a changed man. He’s a searcher who's discovering, however belatedly, that the world's not filled with billions of Harvard students simply looking to connect.
Even as he travels the country, posing for photo ops, speaking like the politician he’ll apparently never be, the frantic reality of Facebook’s internal struggle with harmful content has now been laid bare in these documents. Zuckerberg wants to solve the world’s problems, but clearly has no idea how to fix Facebook. The current solutions smack of desperation.
Instead of using that classic obscenity benchmark—you know it when you see it—Facebook is, in the documents, explaining everything and trying to define context and intent where, in the insane world of online content, there may be none, or it may prove impossible to assign.
Even with algorithms taking the first pass, it’s Facebook's human moderators who are forced to interpret every motive, who decide if something's art or sex, violence or news, hate or free speech.
Often times, there is no objective reality to these situation, or at least one that falls into any of those binaries. In other words, it’s an impossible solution for an impossible situation.
Since he built Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg grew an adult sense of empathy that shines through in his increasingly personal Facebook posts. That’s encouraging. Facebook, on the other hand, is still just a cold robot, emotionlessly posting the best and worst of us. There's no heart. No conscience. Just the cold abyss of terrible choices for a legion of over-taxed moderators who probably wish the world was a better place.
TopicsFacebookSocial Media
WhatsApp announces plans to share user data with Facebook2025-04-26 17:29
英媒:C羅將接受朗尼克考察 他需要證明自己能逼搶2025-04-26 17:22
巴薩有護身符 ?兩逃疑似點球 西甲唯紅藍未被吹點2025-04-26 17:17
首秀平穩 !拉莫斯206天後重返賽場 變巴黎皮爾洛2025-04-26 17:02
How Hyperloop One went off the rails2025-04-26 16:48
迷惑!桑喬單刀破門前 跟跑的拉什福德始終在越位位置2025-04-26 16:46
宛如過山車!米蘭鐵衛破門+直紅 慘遭犯罪式過人2025-04-26 16:27
內馬爾賽後拄拐+穿保護靴離開 社媒發文自我鼓勵2025-04-26 15:52
Fiji wins first2025-04-26 15:50
落後三球半場玩顛球 ?梅縣球鄉致函足協請求調查中冠決賽假球2025-04-26 15:09
Florida hurricane forecast remains uncertain, but trends in state's favor2025-04-26 17:37
卡裏克:未能贏下比賽非常失望 朗尼克沒參與布陣2025-04-26 17:24
巴黎聯賽大名單:梅西內少姆巴佩領銜 拉莫斯入選2025-04-26 17:16
傑拉德挖人鋤刀揮向利物浦神經痛點 克洛普難放人2025-04-26 16:55
Florida hurricane forecast remains uncertain, but trends in state's favor2025-04-26 16:50
米蘭前瞻:紅黑軍迎登頂良機 伊布再度大殺四方 ?2025-04-26 16:12
熱刺VS伯恩利首發 :凱恩孫興慜領銜 搭檔小盧卡斯2025-04-26 16:05
主帥談武磊失單刀 :隻是運氣問題 應該繼續信任他2025-04-26 15:38
Olympic security asks female Iranian fan to drop protest sign2025-04-26 15:26
不願陪跑 ?記者 :C羅今晚不會出席金球獎頒獎典禮2025-04-26 15:07