时间:2025-04-03 14:34:42 来源:网络整理编辑:時尚
In December, it was reported that Apple was looking into bridging the worlds of iOS and macOS even f
In December, it was reported that Apple was looking into bridging the worlds of iOS and macOS even further with universal apps that could run on both platforms.
And now Axios says Apple's still on track to bring iPad apps to Macs this year. No mention of iPhone apps running on Mac. Just iPad apps.
Yuck, no thanks.
SEE ALSO:Why it makes sense for Apple to drop 3D Touch from this year's new iPhoneKnown internally as "Marzipan" according to Bloomberg's report last year, the project would allow developers to create a single version of an app that works with touchscreens (iOS) or mouse and keyboard (Mac).
And while universal compatibility would be the near-term outcome, long-term, this new undertaking could lead to one operating system that runs on allof Apple's devices.
The approach would be similar to what Microsoft already has with its Universal Windows Apps (UWA): Apps that work on desktops, laptops and tablets running Windows 10, and even Windows 10 Mobile phones (RIP).
Heck, Apple's alleged plans to bring iPad apps to Macs has more in common with Android apps running on Chrome OS.
But there's a fundamental difference between Apple and Microsoft/Google. Microsoft needed UWAs for a number of reasons: get more apps on Windows 10 Mobile and get more apps on Windows 10 tablets. Both strategies failed.
Google has had more success. It needs Android apps on Chrome OS because the entire platform is built on cloud-based services and web apps. As robust as some of them are, they still pale in comparison to the kind of features available from a native Windows or Mac app.
Which brings us to iPad apps on Mac. Who needs them? It's not like Macs are starving for apps like Chrome OS is.
There are tons of Mac apps, like Microsoft Office, iMovie, and Adobe Lightroom, with way more features than their watered-down versions on iPad. Why would anyone want fewer features on a computer platform that's designed to help you do more? It doesn't add up.
Now, I know that there are some apps (like the official Twitter app) on iPad that are updated more often than their Mac versions, but those are pretty rare.
Bringing iPad apps to the Mac also raises another question: How do you control them? With keyboard and mouse, dummy! Yeah, Apple would probably make it easy for developers to add keyboard and mouse support to their apps just as devs can with Android apps for Chrome OS, but that defeats the whole point of good app design.
A good iPad app is one that embraces the advantages and limitations of a touchscreen. Does Angry Birdswork with a mouse? It sure does, but it plays better on a touchscreen. Similarly, iMovie, with all of its precise controls and settings, is better suited for a mouse and keyboard than using your chubby fingers.
Universal Windows apps and Android apps work well on PCs and Chromebooks because most of them now come with touchscreens. There are no Macs with touchscreens (and no, accessories like the AirBar that "transform your Mac's screen into a touchscreen" don't count).
Does iPad app support mean Macs with touchscreens are coming? It's possible, but Apple's been pretty against touchscreens and it's unlikely that'll change.
Back in 2010, Steve Jobs said: "We've done tons of user testing on this, and it turns out it doesn't work. Touch surfaces don't want to be vertical."
Apple's been resisting touchscreens on Macs for nearly a decade, even as PCs and Chromebooks have added them.
At the same time, Apple's also defended its reasons for not merging iOS and macOS into any one super OS. In an interview with with CNETfollowing the launch of the controversial Touch Bar on the MacBook Pro, Apple's senior vice president of worldwide marketing Phil Schiller said:
"We did spend a great deal of time looking at this a number of years ago and came to the conclusion that to make the best personal computer, you can’t try to turn MacOS into an iPhone. Conversely, you can’t turn iOS into a Mac…. So each one is best at what they’re meant to be -- and we take what makes sense to add from each, but without fundamentally changing them so they’re compromised."
Instead, Apple prefers to keep iOS and separate because it plays to their strengths:
"It is great to provide two different ways to solve some of the same things, but they also do very unique things that the other doesn’t. Having them separate allows us to explore both, versus trying to force them into one — and only one — model."
What boggles me the most is that iPad apps are reportedly planned for Mac this year, but not iPhone apps. As somebody who loved the Google Pixelbook and greatly enjoyed using Android phone apps in a windowed desktop environment, I'm confused as to why Apple wouldn't bring iPhone apps simultaneously with iPad apps. There are over twice as many iPhone apps than on iPad (2.2 million versus 1 million) and most iPhone apps don't have iPad-optimized versions.
Here are the top five free iPad apps of 2017, according to Apple:
YouTube
Netflix
Messenger
Google Chrome
Not a single one of these needs an Mac app -- all of them work just fine in your desktop browser. I suppose Netflix would be better as a Mac app because then you'd be able to download videos to watch offline, but other than that, there's no reason it needs an app.
Now, compare that list to the top five free iPhone apps of 2017:
Bitmoji
Snapchat
YouTube
Messenger
The No. 1, 2, and 5 apps are all iPhone-only and don't have native iPad apps. You could even scratch Instagram off the list because it's got a web version.
So, as you can see, iPhone apps would be far more desirable on Mac than iPad apps.
Aside from the aforementioned possibility of touchscreen Macs coming, I can only think of two other reasons why Apple would want to push developers to bring iPad apps to the Mac: gaming and greed.
Gaming is a no brainer. Compared to PCs, gaming on Macs is pretty sad. Sure, Macs get a port every once in a while, but you don't buy one expecting to play the latest AAA blockbuster on it. You just don't because most Macs have punier graphics cards than PCs.
iPhone apps would be far more desirable on Mac than iPad apps.
Which only leaves greed. Apple is a business and a successful business is one that makes money. And right now the Mac App Store is languishing. It's not making anywhere near as much money as it could be.
Developers have mostly given up on the Mac App Store -- the most popular apps like Office and Adobe Creative Cloud aren't sold on it -- which means Apple can't get a percentage cut for every download that's sold, like it does from the apps sold on the App Store.
How do you prod developers into getting pumped for the Mac App Store again? You sell them on this idea of iPad apps working on Macs. It's a new revenue stream! It's good for developers and it's good for Apple, company execs will say. Except, like I said, it's not actually that good for developers. Why should devs give Apple a cut when they can sell directly to users and collect in full? It's already working just fine for Microsoft and Adobe.
You know who else it's not good for? Customers. There's already a great place to run iPad apps -- it's called an iPad. Apple already sells two iPad Pros with keyboards and Apple Pencils that are designed from the ground up for touchscreen use. Leave the iPad and Mac separate. There's more than enough room for both to coexist.
Definitely fix the Mac App Store and give developers a reason to sell their apps on there, but don't just shoehorn iPad apps on the Mac and declare it "mission complete."
TopicsAppleiPadiPhone
Researchers create temporary tattoos you can use to control your devices2025-04-03 13:51
津媒:津門虎隊進入"戰時狀態" 8場保級戰就在眼前2025-04-03 13:46
粵媒:如果艾克森沒有選擇放棄中國國籍 也可以稱作留洋球員2025-04-03 13:24
曝鄭智本次執教可能沒有工資 目前隻確定帶8輪聯賽2025-04-03 13:12
You will love/hate Cards Against Humanity's new fortune cookies2025-04-03 13:08
廣州隊更新一線隊名單:阿蘭艾克森缺席 蔣光太洛國富在列2025-04-03 13:06
國米憾負皇馬屈居第二 中場核心報複染紅藏大隱患2025-04-03 13:04
奧運陣容隻留一半!新周期中國女足盼重回正軌2025-04-03 12:57
Carlos Beltran made a very interesting hair choice2025-04-03 12:05
絕不手軟 !拜仁小組全勝晉級 主客場雙殺巴薩入6球2025-04-03 12:02
Mom discovers security cameras hacked, kids' bedroom livestreamed2025-04-03 14:23
中超開賽前亂象頻現 :食宿費用靠賒賬 隊員跟俱樂部攤牌2025-04-03 13:56
西甲資訊:久保建英絕殺馬競 佩德裏獲得科帕獎2025-04-03 13:48
哈維:巴薩被拜仁所屈服 歐聯不應該是我們的目標2025-04-03 13:10
Michael Phelps says goodbye to the pool with Olympic gold2025-04-03 12:58
媒體人:有關方麵希望國企占七成模式拯救廣州隊 明年預算5億2025-04-03 12:58
趙麗娜談重回國家隊:爭取回到自己的巔峰狀態2025-04-03 12:42
天津審計局3月份進駐泰達俱樂部 審計98年以來賬目2025-04-03 12:42
Here's George Takei chilling in zero gravity for the 'Star Trek' anniversary2025-04-03 12:22
北京國安10日出發前往賽區 未有具體成績要求2025-04-03 11:56