时间:2025-04-05 03:11:45 来源:网络整理编辑:綜合
Icelandic whalers have spent much of July ripping back the skin of 65-foot long endangered fin whale
Icelandic whalers have spent much of July ripping back the skin of 65-foot long endangered fin whales in preparation to butcher their meat.
Earlier this month, the commercial whaling company, Hvalur hf, may have also captured and skinned an endangered blue whale -- the largest creature ever known to live on Earth -- according to photographs from the ocean conservation and vigilante group Sea Shepherd.
Most every nation has prohibited killing whales, creatures whose populations were decimated by ruthless whaling practices in the 1800s. International treaties also prohibit the antiquated practice, yet a few nations -- Iceland, Japan, and Norway -- have found legal rationals for hunting whales.
SEE ALSO:After filming giant squids, scientists ponder what else lurks deep within the oceans"People assume whaling is an artifact of the past -- but it’s not," Harry Scheiber, a marine law expert and former director of the University of California at Berkeley's Law of the Sea Institute, said in an interview.
Iceland's recent killing of whales, however, which Sea Shepherd Captain Paul Watson said has numbered 27 fin whales since June 22, has tenuous legal ground -- but the Icelandic justification for hunting whales has still allowed the nation to hunt the mammals with near impunity.
The International Whaling Commission, of which Iceland is member, prohibited killing whales in 1986. Yet, in late 2002 Iceland filed a "reservation" to the treaty, in which they said they would no longer agree to the moratorium on whaling. And legally, Iceland can do this. The whaling commission doesn't create binding law. It's more of a formal agreement of faith.
"See, none of this is compulsory," said Scheiber, noting that any nation can opt out of a provision.
"That’s a loophole."
"If you don’t comply there really aren’t many consequences," Brett Sommermeyer, legal director of Sea Shepherd Legal, an environmental law firm and sister organization to Sea Shepard, said in an interview. "There's public shaming, but there are not any economic consequences."
"It's not the same as national legislation with meaningful penalties," added Catherine Pruett, executive director of Sea Shepard Legal.
So, although many of the world's nations might find the activity repulsive, Iceland has found a way to commercially whale and sell the meat to Japan, some touristy Icelandic establishments, and even a microbrewery that infuses fin whale testicles into its beer.
The International Whaling Commission allows each nation to remain sovereign over its own whaling laws, said Scheiber. And in Iceland, whaling is a proud tradition.
"Icelanders consider themselves a very humane society and are offended that they’re doing something bad by whaling," said Scheiber. "There is a strong tradition of whaling -- it’s handed down from generation to generation."
Not everyone believes Iceland's whaling loophole is legitimate.
"It’s illegal," said Sea Shepherd's captain Watson. "U.S. law says they should be punished for what they’re doing."
Watson is referring to the Magnuson‐Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Reauthorization Act of 2006, which states that foreign nations should be punished for plundering endangered species and engaging in illegal fishing.
Both fin and blue whales are considered endangered under the U.S. Endangered Species Act, meaning "a species is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range."
Of course, the U.S. isn't ever going to raise arms over the killing of threatened whales. Instead, the marine law cites a possible denial of U.S. port access for fishing vessels, and "potential import restrictions on fish."
But Sea Shepherd might consider more direct intervention, said Watson. He gave no specifics, but cited the way the vigilante group spent years chasing Japanese whalers, to apply pressure onto the Japanese government and document exactly how many whales are being killed.
Without efforts like Sea Shepherd's, it's nearly impossible to know exactly what the whaling company Hvalur hf, and its millionaire owner, Kristján Loftsson, are doing at sea.
"This guy can do whatever he wants -- he’s one of the richest men in Iceland," said Watson.
According to the permits issued by the Icelandic government, Hvalur hf can kill fin whales for commercial purposes. But not blue whales, which makes the recent blue whale killing, if proven, a clear violation of Icelandic law.
When Iceland filed its "reservation" to the whale killing moratorium in 2002, it specifically stated that commercial whaling would "under no circumstances" be allowed "without a sound scientific basis" and population management plans.
This makes hunting any endangered, struggling whale species problematic, at best.
"It seems clear that Iceland is in violation of its own reservation, as there can never be a 'sound scientific basis' to commercially hunt endangered whales," said Sommermeyer, the legal director.
What's more, Sommermeyer notes that not every nation has accepted Iceland's 2002 reservation.
"Thus, from the perspective of many nations, Icelandic whaling is illegal because it is undertaken on the basis of an invalid reservation," said Sommermeyer.
For now, Iceland may be holding onto its whaling heritage, hinged to a shaky loophole. But they have little global support for killing endangered, intelligent, and often friendly creatures.
"It’s condemned by most of the world," said Sommermeyer.
"What’s disturbing, of course, is the taking of whales that are clearly an endangered species," saidScheiber.
"The whales have suffered enough," he added.
TopicsAnimalsSustainability
Researchers create temporary tattoos you can use to control your devices2025-04-05 02:53
尤文冬窗5000萬歐急購紫百合神鋒 遭索價7000萬2025-04-05 02:18
歐冠出線形勢:米蘭馬競末輪競速 巴薩需死磕拜仁2025-04-05 02:09
歐冠出線形勢 :米蘭馬競末輪競速 巴薩需死磕拜仁2025-04-05 02:07
Katy Perry talks 'Rise,' her next batch of songs, and how to survive Twitter2025-04-05 01:56
國米時隔10年重返歐冠16強 笑納6000萬歐保底收入2025-04-05 01:12
斯科爾斯:索帥教練組都該滾蛋 要是我就沒臉留下來2025-04-05 00:57
索帥執教曼聯回顧 :救火力挽狂瀾 三年敗光傳奇名2025-04-05 00:55
Visualizing July's astounding global temperature records2025-04-05 00:38
前國腳徐亮哭訴無緣足協教練培訓班:不公平 大家評個理2025-04-05 00:25
Teacher absolutely nails it with new homework policy2025-04-05 02:43
西甲資訊 :皇馬登頂聯賽榜首 哈維執教首戰贏加泰德比2025-04-05 02:37
中超聯賽12月12日重啟 中國足球進入聯賽時間2025-04-05 02:00
歐冠16強:英超4隊+皇仁文巴黎在列 剩5席虛位以待2025-04-05 01:51
You will love/hate Cards Against Humanity's new fortune cookies2025-04-05 01:37
媒體:前泰達助教被有關部門調查 或與前董事長被傳貪腐案有關2025-04-05 01:30
原諒他了?格拉利什女友曬無名指戒指 疑似已訂婚2025-04-05 01:28
本澤馬被判企圖勒索同謀罪 1年緩刑罰款7.5萬歐2025-04-05 00:53
Cat gets stuck in the most awkward position ever2025-04-05 00:44
索帥執教曼聯回顧:救火力挽狂瀾 三年敗光傳奇名2025-04-05 00:26