时间:2025-04-26 18:33:49 来源:网络整理编辑:探索
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has ruled that enabling governments to access everyone's e
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has ruled that enabling governments to access everyone's encrypted messages is a human rights violation. It probably won't stop them from continuing to try, though.
In a 27-page judgement on Tuesday, the ECHR found that Russian legislation concerning online messaging services breach Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to privacy. The case was brought by a Russian Telegram userwho objected to laws requiring messaging services to store users' communications for six months, keep their metadata for one year, and provide law enforcement with keys to decrypt their conversations upon request.
Russia stopped being a party to the Convention in Sept. 2022, six months after it was expelled from the Council of Europe, however the ECHR decided it was still able to hear the case as the events in question occurred prior to this.
SEE ALSO:Warning: Telegram is not end-to-end encrypted by defaultThe applicant successfully argued that it is impossible for Telegram to selectively provide authorities with decryption keys for some users and not others, as the technology simply does not work that way. Creating the ability to access any encrypted messages would enable access to all encrypted messages, weakening security and undermining privacy for everyone across the entire platform.
When encryption is an all or nothing deal, it seems better to err on the side of all.
"In the digital age, technical solutions for securing and protecting the privacy of electronic communications, including measures for encryption, contribute to ensuring the enjoyment of other fundamental rights, such as freedom of expression," wrote the ECHR.
"[I]n the present case the [internet communication organisers'] statutory obligation to decrypt end-to-end encrypted communications risks amounting to a requirement that providers of such services weaken the encryption mechanism for all users; it is accordingly not proportionate to the legitimate aims pursued."
The ECHR also considered Russia's data retention requirements "extremely broad," with "exceptionally wide-ranging and serious" implications which would require significant safeguards against abuse. Unfortunately, such safeguards were nowhere to be found.
The court accepted the applicant's claim that Russia's laws violate the right to privacy by enabling the government to arbitrarily access anyone's communication logs, even without cause. Russian law enforcement is not required to show messaging services judicial authorisation before accessing decryption keys, theoretically enabling them to conduct secret extrajudicial surveillance of users.
"Although the possibility of improper action by a dishonest, negligent or overzealous official can never be completely ruled out whatever the system, the Court considers that a system, such as the Russian one, which enables the secret services to access directly the Internet communications of each and every citizen without requiring them to show an interception authorisation to the communications service provider, or to anyone else, is particularly prone to abuse," wrote the ECHR.
The ECHR case concerned a 2017 order from Russia's Federal Security Service, which demanded Telegram provide information allowing it to decrypt communications from six users suspected of "terrorism-related activities." Telegram refused to comply with the order, stating that it was impossible to do so without creating a backdoor that would weaken encryption for all its users. It also noted that the users in question had activated Telegram's optional end-to-end encryption, meaning even the company couldn't access their messages.
Russia subsequently fined and blocked Telegram in the country. Though the ban was eventually lifted in 2020, it was upheld in domestic courts despite challenges by the current applicant and others. The applicant therefore took the matter to the ECHR, alleging that he was unable to get justice for the violation of their human rights through the Russian courts.
Tuesday's ECHR ruling awarded the applicant €10,000 ($10,725) in damages, though whether he'll actually receive that money is another question. In 2015 Russia passed a domestic law enabling its Constitutional Court to overturn ECHR rulings, a move which Human Rights Watch criticised as undermining victims' ability to seek justice.
Governments around the world have tried forcing tech companies to weaken their encryption for years. In 2016, Apple CEO Tim Cook publicly opposedthe U.S. government's request for an iPhone encryption backdoor, stating that creating one would have "chilling" privacy and surveillance implications. Nevertheless, the U.S. has continued to pressure Apple to build a way for law enforcement to unlock people's devices. WhatsApp also rejected a request from the UK government to build a backdoorto its encryption in 2017 — a conflict that could still end with it pulling out of the country altogether.
Encryption is further being threatened in the U.S. by the Eliminating Abusive and Rampant Neglect of Interactive Technologies (EARN IT) Act, proposed legislation which was introduced to Congress in 2020. At the time, messaging app Signal warned that it may not be able to continue operating in the U.S. if the bill passed, alleging that the act would undermine end-to-end encryption. The bill was later amended in an attempt to address such concerns, though it wasn't enough to assuage privacy experts.
The ECHR's ruling this week is unlikely to put this long running encryption issue to rest. Still, it's a notable victory for privacy and security advocates across the globe.
TopicsApps & SoftwareCybersecurityPrivacy
Dog elected for third term as mayor of Minnesota town2025-04-26 18:33
海口確認承辦中超比賽 新賽季大概率6月3日開賽2025-04-26 17:34
切爾西足總杯慘遭三連亞 近3年3次決賽點球負紅軍2025-04-26 17:23
歐戰紀律處罰決定公布 納賽爾大鬧伯納烏無下文2025-04-26 17:02
Nancy Pelosi warns colleagues after info hacked2025-04-26 16:58
亞洲杯中國組委會:難以對亞洲杯按完全開放模式辦賽作出承諾2025-04-26 16:40
國安奔赴梅州先接受7天醫學隔離觀察 結束後才可正常備戰2025-04-26 16:29
武磊很大概率最終繼續留隊 莫雷諾下課短時間內影響不大2025-04-26 16:27
This chart shows just how high Simone Biles can jump2025-04-26 16:25
德乙大結局:沙爾克不萊梅升德甲 漢堡進升級附加賽2025-04-26 16:04
Whyd voice2025-04-26 18:30
廣州城股改有進展 ?幾家國企已將近億元經費打到共同賬戶2025-04-26 18:19
前河北隊外援席爾瓦試訓巴甲隊未果 不打算回中超效力2025-04-26 17:47
曝足協退還調節費因市場監管總局介入 就合規問題派員走訪2025-04-26 17:23
Nate Parker is finally thinking about the woman who accused him of rape2025-04-26 17:20
切爾西足總杯慘遭三連亞 近3年3次決賽點球負紅軍2025-04-26 17:01
扳回一城!格拉利什抽射破門 曼城暫12025-04-26 16:56
巴黎專用條款 ?曼城哈蘭德仍存解約金 最高2億歐2025-04-26 16:50
There's a big piece of fake chicken stuck to this phone case2025-04-26 16:44
泰山結束拉練收官日1天2賽 克雷桑最快10天後合練2025-04-26 15:55