时间:2025-04-03 15:04:09 来源:网络整理编辑:焦點
My grandmother's funeral was quiet. I was young, so I can recall only a sliver of that day in Melbou
My grandmother's funeral was quiet. I was young, so I can recall only a sliver of that day in Melbourne, but I do remember the silence.
In places like Australia, the public tradition of mourning is largely that of Anglo-Saxon stoicism. My grandmother was neither British nor Christian, but what I remember as the thorough decorum of her passing formed my idea of "proper mourning."
Social media put an end to all that. On Twitter and Facebook the practice is loud. It's noisy and decadent. Even obnoxious.
SEE ALSO:Carrie Fisher was a bold advocate for people with mental illnessIn a year marked by the worst of everything, the march of celebrity death was a horribly steady and repetitive drumbeat.
You might have thought we would tire of public prostrations of anguish, but the furore that marked David Bowie's passing in February has seemed more than matched by the double gut punch of George Michael and Carrie Fisher in the twilight of this year.
The public wailing and tweets about "2016 being the worst year ever" when there have been and will be worse had seemed tawdry to me, but I regret feeling that way now.
After Bowie's death, I was "grief policing," as Megan Garber put it in The Atlantic.
Grief policing may be a fitting thing for a culture that has elevated ’you're doing it wrong’ to a kind of Hegelian taunt, that treats every social-media-ed expression as a basis for an argument, and that is on top of it all generally extremely confused about how to mourn ‘properly’. Such policing, however, very much misses the point.
The grief police are not thinking of Carrie Fisher's daughter when they tell you not to tweet. Most often, they're uncomfortable with either the idea of mourning celebrity or the triviality of social media as a forum for expressing bereavement.
The impulse is to control how people express their feelings in public, very separate from supporting the actual bereaved.
Celebrity culture is certainly a problematic form of mass distraction, but the work of artists can wake you up. My childhood memories do not coalesce strongly around Bowie, Michael or Fisher as they do for others, but like Muhammad Ali and Prince, I understood them to be giants.
Along with other members of the "grief police," I was not immune when it suited me. My parents listened to Leonard Cohen when I was a child, so like the typical cliché, I listened to "Marianne" after his passing and cried.
I almost tweeted about it but held back, and not because I had nothing to say.
If you think Facebook platitudes are uniquely bad, you must have never stood in a greeting line at a funeral home.
Others have expressed their disgust with the mania of public celebrity mourning, as shells rained down on Syria, Yemen and elsewhere. The social outpouring seemed grotesque in comparison to images of broken bodies.
To those people, you are right. But also, will that shame you're trying to inflict be useful? I don't think so.
People can mourn all types of tragedies at once, of course. A rigorous lack of mourning for the passing of art and those who make it isn't something to bully people with. Art is how we process and understand the world. When you lose an artist such as Prince or Bowie, you lament the closing of a unique portal.
Unfortunately for those who'd prefer their mourning relegated to the family home or to the church, grief takes place on social media because it's where we are.
Lovers of Cohen's or Prince's music are part of a chosen family, no less significant if they come together under a hashtag rather than a roof. And if you think Facebook platitudes are uniquely bad, you must have never stood in a greeting line at a funeral home.
In a year marked by "fake news" filtered through Twitter and Facebook, as well as real news that seemed devastating and too intractable to grasp, the death of a beloved artist is a tangible fact. They were alive, now they're dead. You can hold onto that and feel its edges, and that is comforting.
The rituals of public grief are sentimental, sometimes to the point of grossness, but only because we are sentimental. If you're asking people to put logic over feeling on social media -- you can try, but you will not succeed. Ask yourself if you really want to.
TopicsSocial Media
Nancy Pelosi warns colleagues after info hacked2025-04-03 14:54
紐卡有意貝爾卻貼冷屁股 大聖隻想履行完皇馬合同2025-04-03 14:38
劉彬彬 :絕殺越南有利於備戰 戰沙特已做相應的部署2025-04-03 14:17
米盧受訪為國足戰沙特支招 直言B組澳大利亞更強2025-04-03 13:53
Did our grandparents have the best beauty advice?2025-04-03 13:53
國足戰沙特對未來走向有決定性意義 武磊暫列射手榜次席2025-04-03 13:11
國足戰沙特對未來走向有決定性意義 武磊暫列射手榜次席2025-04-03 13:06
偵察機變轟炸機 ?弗裏克激活維爾納 5場5球成一哥2025-04-03 13:03
This coloring book is here for all your relationship goals2025-04-03 12:53
河南換帥足協杯提供磨合良機 球隊不會改變既定打法2025-04-03 12:24
This chart shows just how high Simone Biles can jump2025-04-03 15:03
媒體人怒斥足協女足換帥潛規則 禍害中國足球多年2025-04-03 15:01
李毅:沙特是最難的客場 以平常心出戰或有奇效2025-04-03 14:44
熱刺總監否認凱恩離隊傳聞:他愛球隊 對其有歸屬感2025-04-03 14:27
Give your kitchen sponge a rest on this adorable bed2025-04-03 14:22
英格蘭前瞻:爭勝奠定出線基礎 凱恩追趕魯尼紀錄2025-04-03 13:56
卡納瓦羅談如何與韋世豪相處 直言高準翼技術足以留洋2025-04-03 13:21
沙特媒體分析主隊下半場火力更猛 戰中國目標刷分2025-04-03 12:53
Dramatic photo captures nun texting friends after Italy earthquake2025-04-03 12:52
沙特主帥:同組對手都很難對付 我們將捍衛沙特的名字2025-04-03 12:37