时间:2025-04-26 21:03:19 来源:网络整理编辑:知識
When it rained misinformation during election season, it poured policy updates from tech platforms.
When it rained misinformation during election season, it poured policy updates from tech platforms. Too bad none of them thought to bring a sturdy umbrella in the first place.
The Mozilla Foundation, a nonprofit which advocates for a secure, open internet that supports democracy, has released an interactive timeline that shows the misinformation policy changes online platforms made before, during, and after the 2020 election, and how those actions intersect with major political and cultural events that spurred misinformation. Mozilla is most widely known for its Firefox browser, but the nonprofit also tracks online misinformation in an effort to improve tech policies.
Mozilla will be releasing a series of blog posts with learnings from the tool, but a major takeaway is that platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube were largely reactive, rather than proactive, when it came to making and (crucially) enforcing major policy changes.
"Creating the visualization made it obvious that there were bursts of activity," Jon Lloyd, Mozilla's lead researcher for the project, said. "A lot of the changes that platforms were making were happening after millions of Americans had already cast their ballots, or, a lot of the time, they were even coming after election day itself."
In October, Mozilla launched a campaign pressuring social platforms to limit misinformation. That included a table that logged and compared every major platform's misinformation policies. The need for a third-party compendium showed how poorly platforms handled their misinformation strategies. It was woefully unclear what the most up-to-date policies were, and who was doing what.
"It was very hard to determine what platforms were doing, because they were releasing statements, they had policy documents, but also they were releasing blogs, there was nothing more in place," Lloyd said. "What we wanted to do is just make sure that all of those changes that they were making in order to address this misinformation problem were in just one central resource that was easy to parse."
The table turned out not to be enough. It did not capture the upheaval that came with Trump's refusal to concede the election, the Capitol Hill riot — and the deluge of bans and updates that followed.
To broaden the scope in terms of both time and context, researchers constructed a timeline from October 2019 to January 2021. It compares when Facebook, Twitter, TikTok, and YouTube intervened due to misinformation and when political and misinformation events took place.
Users can see policy changes and enforcements (which both fall under the umbrella of what the researchers call "interventions") taken by all four platforms, or one by one. Click on a particular name, like Facebook, to see data from just that one company, or hover over points on the graph to see the interventions a platform took at that time.
On the timeline, you can see events like the first Trump impeachment (remember that?), Trump's first claims of mail-in-ballot fraud, election day, notable polls of public sentiment, and the Capitol Hill riot. Specific moments that, according to the data, served as flashpoints for change on social media.
The plots on the graph intersect with those interventions. Presenting the information this way makes it easy to see how platform action often followed — or reacted to — notable events. For example, amid mass protests against police brutality after the killing of George Floyd, Twitter began putting warning labels on Trump's tweets for glorifying violence.
"Tracking each change by the platforms, we noticed that they often came in a flurry in response to something that was making the news, often something Trump may have said," Lloyd said.
Looking at the trend lines of the graph is interesting, too. While misinformation policies and enforcements began 2020 with a trickle, they snowballed in early January 2021 around the time of the Capitol Hill riot. Many of those interventions were banning Trump.
The timeline only encompasses January 2020 to January 2021, but the story of how platforms handle misinformation is far from over. Mozilla researchers found that platforms have already begun rolling back misinformation protections they put in place during the election, which Lloyd sees as a recognition by platforms that "they know that type of political content is a major vector for misinformation, but in reversing the ban they're really saying that they're willing to put their own profits above the health of our democracy and our society."
Recently, YouTube said that it would lift Trump's ban when there was a lowered risk of violence. But Lloyd sees this move as backpedaling, potentially off a cliff.
"YouTube said it will restore Trump's account when the rest of violence falls, which I guess for me begs another question," Lloyd said. "They've done such a bad job of assessing that risk of violence so far. So how can we possibly trust them to make the right call again?"
If the new timeline is any indication, we can't.
TopicsActivismFacebookTwitterPolitics
Chinese gymnastics team horrifies crowd with human jump rope2025-04-26 20:33
梅西和阿根廷隊能捧起大力神杯嗎?(歐洲杯阿根廷參加了嗎)2025-04-26 20:31
粉絲堅信梅西已鎖定金球獎 外媒:C羅或再度缺席頒獎禮(c羅幾時加盟皇馬的)2025-04-26 20:24
阿根廷球員無比信任梅西,隻要他在場上喘氣 ,就覺得有機會(阿根廷聯合會杯亞軍)2025-04-26 20:20
Give your kitchen sponge a rest on this adorable bed2025-04-26 19:57
【波盈足球】 影姆巴佩缺席梅西歡迎會 弟弟送上怪異表情引熱議 ( 美聯社,歡迎會 )2025-04-26 19:47
他才21歲 ,就是梅西身邊的最強帶刀侍衛,還拿到了世界杯最佳新秀(梅西 世界級 停球)2025-04-26 19:40
正式敲定!C羅決定加盟利雅得勝利,梅西喜獲2年新合同(c羅加盟嗎)2025-04-26 19:17
Give your kitchen sponge a rest on this adorable bed2025-04-26 18:25
梅西拉莫斯同時首發巴黎逆轉3比1獲勝 世預賽中國男籃雙殺日本 !(11.28晚報)(巴黎宣布梅西)2025-04-26 18:20
More than half of women in advertising have faced sexual harassment, report says2025-04-26 20:58
點球戰勝法國 阿根廷36年後再捧大力神杯(阿根廷男足冠軍)2025-04-26 20:53
西媒曝重磅內幕!C羅加盟曼聯前被推薦至巴薩但被拒絕(c羅加盟巴黎聖日耳曼)2025-04-26 20:38
7個進球4個點球含金量低 ?梅西配不配當球王另說,巴薩就別加戲了(巴薩解釋不續約梅西原因長的好看)2025-04-26 19:44
Tourist survives for month in frozen New Zealand wilderness after partner dies2025-04-26 19:43
皇馬為姆巴佩準備10億歐元 !姆巴佩如果加盟皇馬 ,能超越C羅嗎 ?(尤文官宣c羅正式加盟)2025-04-26 19:36
35歲加冕球王 !梅西不會從國家隊退役 ,繼續征戰 !(梅西不是退役了嗎怎麽還加入大巴黎)2025-04-26 19:35
影響力暴增!梅西回複中國藝人,阿根廷隊帶著世界杯歸國萬人空巷(奧運會阿根廷隊)2025-04-26 18:49
Over 82,000 evacuate as Blue Cut fire rapidly spreads in southern California2025-04-26 18:26
本澤馬35歲生日宣布從國家隊退役:故事結束了!我為我的成績驕傲(本澤馬退出法國國家隊)2025-04-26 18:21