时间:2025-07-19 06:32:55 来源:网络整理编辑:熱點
Civil servants in Australia can criticise the country's government on Twitter, so long as they do it
Civil servants in Australia can criticise the country's government on Twitter, so long as they do it under a fake name and outside of work.
That's the latest result in the case of a former employee of Australia's immigration department, Michaela Banerji, who was sacked for misconduct in 2013 after posting anonymous tweets that were highly critical of her department and the government's refugee policy.
Banerji made a claim for compensation due to depression and anxiety that was brought on by her firing — and on Monday, she won.
SEE ALSO:The Russian Embassy Twitter accounts troll like Trump, but with better EnglishShe told the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of Australia (AATA) that the motivation for her tweets "was essentially to explain the obligations that our country holds in relation to the Refugee Convention."
"Think of the deaths we are responsible for in Iraq! Think of the refugees we have created by our invasion of Iraq!" read one tweet, posted by the username @LaLegale. "Where states fail to offer legal asylum to refugees, that state fails. #itsnotwelfare," reads another.
The compensation claim was initially denied because the firing was deemed to be a reasonable action, but on Monday, the AATA overturned the rejected claim.
Tweet may have been deleted
Banerji had argued she had a constitutional right to freely engage in political discussion, and the AATA agreed.
Her firing by the department had "unacceptably trespassed on the implied freedom of political communication," and therefore was unlawful, according to the tribunal's deputy president Gary Humphries and member Bernard Hughson.
Since Banerji had made an effort to ensure her tweets were anonymous, it effectively dispelled the department's argument that the comments would make her appear biased or unprofessional.
"A comment made anonymously cannot rationally be used to draw conclusions about the professionalism or impartiality of the public service," Humphries and Hughson noted.
"Such conclusions might conceivably be open if the comments were explicitly attributed to, say, an unnamed public servant, but that hypothetical situation does not apply to Ms Banerji."
Furthermore, Banerji had tweeted outside of work hours, not at work, and not on work equipment — except in one case where she retweeted a critical comment about the department, although the tribunal found it to be still anonymous.
Humphries and Hughson said department efforts to restrict anonymous comments by its employees would be like a "thoughtcrime," as per George Orwell's 1984.
Banerji had presented her case to Australia's High Court in 2013, where an injunction to prevent her sacking was turned down.
Judge Warwick Neville said at the time her constitutional right to free political expression did "not provide a licence ... to breach a contract of employment."
The ruling is significant for Australia, given the new social media guidelines introduced last year for the country's civil servants, which stipulate that “liking” or “sharing” a post that’s critical of the government could result in disciplinary action.
TopicsSocial MediaTwitter
Tributes flow after death of former Singapore president S.R. Nathan2025-07-19 06:11
世界杯4強全部出爐 !半決賽對陣敲定 ,實力懸殊,沒有強強對話(克羅地亞淘汰阿根廷了嗎)2025-07-19 06:11
【波盈足球】 影內馬呼對方巴掌還假摔 職業生涯第5次被趕出場 ( 巴黎,聖日 )2025-07-19 06:04
【四強開戰】:克羅地亞難現冷門,阿根廷終將進決賽(西班牙vs克羅地亞誰厲害)2025-07-19 06:01
PlayStation Now game streaming is coming to PC2025-07-19 05:57
阿根廷vs克羅地亞曆史交鋒戰績哪隊強 哪隊比較厲害贏麵大(克羅地亞與阿根廷交戰記錄)2025-07-19 05:38
世界杯阿根廷vs克羅地亞誰厲害能贏 克羅地亞對阿根廷賽事前瞻分析(克羅地亞上次進四強)2025-07-19 05:27
足球比賽的基本規則,你了解多少呢(足球守門員比賽規則)2025-07-19 04:46
Xiaomi accused of copying again, this time by Jawbone2025-07-19 03:53
世界杯四強戰打響 !世界杯,阿根廷VS克羅地亞,梅西對決莫德裏奇!(世界杯克羅地亞和阿根廷誰厲害)2025-07-19 03:51
Fyvush Finkel, Emmy winner for 'Picket Fences,' dies at 932025-07-19 06:14
梅西超越馬拉多納創多項紀錄,11大數據完勝C羅(梅西個人進球數)2025-07-19 05:51
2022世界杯半決賽 ,法國對陣摩洛哥預測比分(2022世界杯比分圖)2025-07-19 05:34
世界杯四強看點之:阿根廷vs克羅地亞,點球大戰不是最後的歸宿,今晚來點刺激的 !(克羅地亞實力怎麽樣)2025-07-19 05:15
Early Apple2025-07-19 04:24
Z世代2022世界杯觀賽及消費行為呈現五大特征(2022世界杯成績)2025-07-19 04:21
世界杯阿根廷vs克羅地亞誰厲害能贏 克羅地亞對阿根廷賽事前瞻分析(克羅地亞上次進四強)2025-07-19 03:58
最初的夢想 最後的機會(梅西賽前亮相)2025-07-19 03:54
These glasses hide a fitness tracker on your face2025-07-19 03:50
四年之後完美複仇!梅西傳射製霸全場 ,阿根廷八年之後再進決賽(梅西進球後的阿根廷)2025-07-19 03:47