时间:2025-04-04 09:48:42 来源:网络整理编辑:熱點
Civil servants in Australia can criticise the country's government on Twitter, so long as they do it
Civil servants in Australia can criticise the country's government on Twitter, so long as they do it under a fake name and outside of work.
That's the latest result in the case of a former employee of Australia's immigration department, Michaela Banerji, who was sacked for misconduct in 2013 after posting anonymous tweets that were highly critical of her department and the government's refugee policy.
Banerji made a claim for compensation due to depression and anxiety that was brought on by her firing — and on Monday, she won.
SEE ALSO:The Russian Embassy Twitter accounts troll like Trump, but with better EnglishShe told the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of Australia (AATA) that the motivation for her tweets "was essentially to explain the obligations that our country holds in relation to the Refugee Convention."
"Think of the deaths we are responsible for in Iraq! Think of the refugees we have created by our invasion of Iraq!" read one tweet, posted by the username @LaLegale. "Where states fail to offer legal asylum to refugees, that state fails. #itsnotwelfare," reads another.
The compensation claim was initially denied because the firing was deemed to be a reasonable action, but on Monday, the AATA overturned the rejected claim.
Tweet may have been deleted
Banerji had argued she had a constitutional right to freely engage in political discussion, and the AATA agreed.
Her firing by the department had "unacceptably trespassed on the implied freedom of political communication," and therefore was unlawful, according to the tribunal's deputy president Gary Humphries and member Bernard Hughson.
Since Banerji had made an effort to ensure her tweets were anonymous, it effectively dispelled the department's argument that the comments would make her appear biased or unprofessional.
"A comment made anonymously cannot rationally be used to draw conclusions about the professionalism or impartiality of the public service," Humphries and Hughson noted.
"Such conclusions might conceivably be open if the comments were explicitly attributed to, say, an unnamed public servant, but that hypothetical situation does not apply to Ms Banerji."
Furthermore, Banerji had tweeted outside of work hours, not at work, and not on work equipment — except in one case where she retweeted a critical comment about the department, although the tribunal found it to be still anonymous.
Humphries and Hughson said department efforts to restrict anonymous comments by its employees would be like a "thoughtcrime," as per George Orwell's 1984.
Banerji had presented her case to Australia's High Court in 2013, where an injunction to prevent her sacking was turned down.
Judge Warwick Neville said at the time her constitutional right to free political expression did "not provide a licence ... to breach a contract of employment."
The ruling is significant for Australia, given the new social media guidelines introduced last year for the country's civil servants, which stipulate that “liking” or “sharing” a post that’s critical of the government could result in disciplinary action.
TopicsSocial MediaTwitter
Here's what 'Game of Thrones' actors get up to between takes2025-04-04 09:28
你敢信?巴黎收到大量收購申請 其中一份來自中國2025-04-04 08:55
姆巴佩薩拉赫極限1換1? 克洛普:買哈蘭德不好玩2025-04-04 08:50
萊萬與巴薩越來越近已會麵2次 紅藍退出薩拉赫爭奪2025-04-04 08:27
These glasses hide a fitness tracker on your face2025-04-04 08:23
郝偉透露莫伊塞斯將離隊 李鬆益基本確定加盟申花2025-04-04 08:21
馬德興:中超三強執意戰亞冠 練兵之名遮不住羞2025-04-04 07:45
深度:球員權力體係坑死曼聯 肖可拍電影毀滅紅魔2025-04-04 07:40
Tesla's rumored P100D could make Ludicrous mode even more Ludicrous2025-04-04 07:34
巴媒 :卡爾德克已遭遇深圳隊5個月欠薪 將向FIFA提起訴訟2025-04-04 07:13
Olympics official on Rio's green diving pool: 'Chemistry is not an exact science'2025-04-04 09:07
什麽橋段?普拉蒂尼起訴因凡蒂諾 舉報其貪汙腐敗2025-04-04 09:04
西甲資訊 :巴薩升入積分榜第二 皇馬賽季中簽約新援2025-04-04 09:03
山東隊核心孫準浩結束隔離 與工作人員合影(圖)2025-04-04 09:02
Major earthquake and multiple aftershocks rock central Italy2025-04-04 08:44
郝偉透露莫伊塞斯將離隊 李鬆益基本確定加盟申花2025-04-04 08:41
於根偉 :新賽季球隊有補強 但不能盲目樂觀要擺正位置2025-04-04 08:30
深度:每逢大戰必有斬獲 德布勞內正重新定義偉大2025-04-04 08:19
Fiji wins first2025-04-04 07:36
馬內連場KO薩拉赫後超傑拉德 紅軍進四強已無懸念2025-04-04 07:23