时间:2025-05-09 16:34:48 来源:网络整理编辑:知識
Welcome toFix It, our series examining projects we love — save for one tiny change we wish we
Welcome toFix It, our series examining projects we love — save for one tiny change we wish we could make.
For a movie that was released 20 years ago, The Fellowship of the Ring — and the entirety of Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy — still looks amazing. The visuals hold up, with everything from the Balrog to the fiery wastes of Mordor appearing real. It's so easy to immerse yourself in the films' version of Middle Earth, and Jackson and his team's ability to so completely realize J.R.R. Tolkien's fantasy world is the trilogy's greatest achievement.
The problem with all this visual excellence is that it makes one bizarre sequence — and one shot in particular — stick out like a sore thumb.
A little over an hour into The Fellowship of the Ring, Frodo (Elijah Wood) is wounded by a Nazgûl's Morgul blade at Weathertop, so Arwen (Liv Tyler) brings him to Rivendell for some much-needed Elvish healing. As Frodo risks succumbing to the blade's poison, the film moves into a dreamlike series of cross dissolves showing Rivendell, Frodo, and Elrond (Hugo Weaving). It also includes this truly weird shot:
Tweet may have been deleted
The sequence only lasts 15 seconds, but it is jarring. Up until this point, we've been watching a fantasy epic unfold. Arwen literally just summoned a flood of watery horses to wash the Nazgûl downriver. The movie follows that badass sequence by taking a hard left into a '90s music video.
It's a mini fever dream, which I will grudgingly admit makes sense in context. This imagery mimics Frodo's disorientation and places the audience in a similar state of mind. Unfortunately, it just looks far cornier than anything we've seen in The Fellowship of the Ring— off-putting, even. Having transparent Elrond gaze directly into our eyes while transparent Frodo drifts away into dreamland is nothing short of surreal.
That strangeness is the problem: The Lord of the Rings trilogy is so good because it feels so real. Middle Earth is fully actualized thanks to the incredible amount of detail put into every aspect of these movies, from costumes to props to visual effects. A moment as bizarre as this breaks up the visual language of The Lord of the Rings, and in doing so breaks our immersion.
The good news is that the illusion isn't broken for long. The movie continues with Gandalf's (Ian McKellen) escape from Isengard, and not long after that we get the iconic scene that is the Council of Elrond. Within five minutes, transparent Elrond's intense gaze is completely gone from my memory.
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is so good because it feels so real. A moment as bizarre as this breaks up the visual language of The Lord of the Rings, and in doing so breaks our immersion.
Still, every time I re-watch The Lord of the Rings, I'm thrown off by the cheesiness of these 15 seconds. These are the same movies that revolutionized CGI with Gollum (Andy Serkis) and painstakingly constructed weapons, armor, and miniatures of entire cities. All three films deservedly won the Academy Award for Best Visual Effects.
With all that in mind, these 15 seconds of strangeness simply aren't up to par with the rest of the movies.
In the grand scheme of things, this sequence doesn't make a huge dent in The Fellowship of the Ring's impact. Maybe I'll even grow to love it. After all, some of the trilogy's cornier moments have become some of my favorite parts of the films (which are, in turn, my favorite movies of all time). I am fully aware that the Fellowship's reunion at the end of The Return of the King is cheesy, but I bawl every time I see the hobbits bouncing around and hugging each other.
And what about the many, many memes The Lord of the Rings has spawned? It's nearly impossible not to laugh at Legolas's (Orlando Bloom) cry of "they're taking the hobbits to Isengard!" or Boromir's (Sean Bean) assertion that "one does not simply walk into Mordor." These are moments that should be serious, but their lives beyond the films make it hard not to chuckle at them, even in context. With its corny visuals and music video vibe, it's not so hard to believe that Frodo's bizarre introduction to Rivendell could reach meme status at some point.
Until that day comes, transparent Elrond continues to haunt my dreams, and my Lord of the Rings rewatches, if only for 15 seconds at a time.
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is streaming on HBO Max.
Honda's all2025-05-09 16:26
An NBA team's season of discontent boils over on Instagram2025-05-09 16:26
Barron Trump is not particularly impressed with his dad's inauguration2025-05-09 16:11
These barbed wire dreamcatchers help support the resistance at Standing Rock2025-05-09 15:45
Two states took big steps this week to get rid of the tampon tax2025-05-09 15:37
Ewan McGregor and Piers Morgan feud on Twitter over Women's March2025-05-09 15:33
This Bollywood actor has launched stickers styled on looks from her movies2025-05-09 15:09
Black Lives Matter app lets social media users mark themselves 'unsafe' in America2025-05-09 14:41
Make money or go to Stanford? Katie Ledecky is left with an unfair choice.2025-05-09 14:32
What is breadcrumbing on dating apps?2025-05-09 13:48
Watch MTV's Video Music Awards 2016 livestream2025-05-09 16:33
Iran born BBC journalist tweets odyssey of going through U.S. airports2025-05-09 15:53
Forget Prince George, the Prince of Bhutan is the OG royal baby2025-05-09 15:29
British celebrities take a stand against Trump's Muslim ban2025-05-09 15:20
Balloon fanatic Tim Kaine is also, of course, very good at harmonica2025-05-09 15:10
Joel Embiid's brilliant tweet tweaks Trump where it hurts after NBA All2025-05-09 14:47
British celebrities take a stand against Trump's Muslim ban2025-05-09 14:31
YouTube is playing around with video thumbnails that move like GIFs2025-05-09 14:12
Cat gets stuck in the most awkward position ever2025-05-09 13:59
'Saturday Night Live' writer suspended over Barron Trump tweet2025-05-09 13:49