时间:2024-09-20 08:12:48 来源:网络整理编辑:休閑
Donald Trump might sue the New York Times. The Timesmight just want that to happen.If Trump sues the
Donald Trump might sue the New York Times. TheTimesmight just want that to happen.
If Trump sues the Timesover its reporting, the Republican nominee for president risks opening up his personal life to lawyers, providing access that would otherwise be private. He'd also almost certainly be the subject of a deposition, in which he, his family and many others would have to answer questions under oath about his behavior with women.
SEE ALSO:Insult after insult: All of Trump's ugly campaign rhetoric in one place"It's his butler. It's the help around him generally. It's his kids. It's his ex wife. It's his girlfriends if you can identify them ... it's all that stuff," said Stuart Karle, general counsel at North Base Media and an adjunct professor at the Columbia School of Journalism. "It would just be a rich vain of yuck about Donald Trump."
It all began on Wednesday night when the newspaper published the accounts of two women who claimed to have been groped by the presidential candidate. Trump denied the claims and attacked the Times.
That could have been chalked up to just another dust up between Trump and a media outlet. He's had plenty through his campaign, even operating an informal blacklist that included the Times and other outlets, such as the Washington Postand Politico.
Not this time. The Times,the Trump campaign feinted,had gone too far. Sources from the Trump camp told numerous reporters that a lawsuit was being drawn up. One of Trump's lawyers sent a letter to the Timesdemanding a retraction. The Timesfired back with the legal equivalent of "come at me, bro."
The newspaper has a good reason to be cocky. A lawsuit would mean that Trump would be subject to a legal process called "discovery," in which lawyers for the Timesare allowed to pore through the relevant histories of those involved in the case.
Tweet may have been deleted
In this case, that would mean Trump's sexual and romantic history. The inquisition would not necessarily stop with the women from the Timesstory.
"They might start talking about other women that were involved to see if there was a pattern of conduct," said Chip Stewart, associate dean of the college of communication at Texas Christian University. "They could be asking a lot of questions that would be embarrassing to him."
"There’s a big difference between Trump threatening to sue and actually suing -- and he often never follows through ..."
Tim O'Brien knows this better than almost anyone. Trump sued O'Brien in 2006 over an allegation in O'Brien's book "TrumpNation" that The Donald was worth far less than he led people to believe.
As part of that lawsuit, O'Brien's lawyers deposed Trump as part of the discovery process. Trump was caught lying 30 times.
"Discovery can have a very, very long long arm with people in the business world. And that's why a lot of them are careful about it and aren't as flagrant about threatening to sue people," O'Brien said in an interview with Mashable.
O'Brien, now the executive editor of Bloomberg Gadfly and Bloomberg View, assured reporters on Thursday that they didn't have much to fear. In an article entitled "Don't Fear Trump's Lawsuits. He'll Keep Losing," O'Brien noted Trump will not want to open himself up to discovery.
"...there’s a big difference between Trump threatening to sue and actually suing -- and he often never follows through with his threats anyway," O'Brien wrote. "So exhale and keep reporting aggressively all of you scribes."
A Reuters report found that despite many threats, Trump hasn't sued a newspaper in 30 years.
The Times did not respond to a request for comment on the discovery process.
Maybe Trump would be willing to suffer through discovery if he stood a legitimate chance of convincing a jury that the Timescommitted libel.
Trump, however, stands little chance.
In this case, Trump's lawyers would need to show that the Timesacted with "actual malice" -- meaning that not only are the claims untrue, but that the Timesknew that the claims were untrue. Also, because Trump is a public figure, he would need to prove that those false claims defamed him -- something that the Timeslawyers pointed out will be difficult to do due to Trump's own public statements.
The paper would certainly end up having to pay some legal fees to defend itself against a theoretical Trump lawsuit, but that might end up being money well spent.
Writing on the legal blog Above the Law, Elie Mystal argued that the documents the Times would collect during the discovery process would be extremely valuable to its reporting.
Other documents, or videos, about Trump’s past sexual conduct would become relevant. Trump would be deposed, under oath, about his sexual escapades. The Times would LOVE Donald Trump to sue them over this. They’d never settle. There would be a public trial where all this stuff would come out. They’d win a freaking Pulitzer.
Even if Trump were to sue, none of this would play out particularly quickly. Civil lawsuits tend to drag on for months or years. Trump almost certainly wouldn't be deposed until well after the election.
That's a prospect that wouldn't seem to be appealing to Trump. If he wins, he's a sitting president forced to confront allegations of sexual assault. If he loses, he's a failed politician forced to confront allegations of sexual assault.
TopicsDonald TrumpElections
Katy Perry talks 'Rise,' her next batch of songs, and how to survive Twitter2024-09-20 07:35
中國裁判組留守西亞執法亞冠 向世界杯席位發起最後衝擊2024-09-20 07:00
深度:每逢大戰必有斬獲 德布勞內正重新定義偉大2024-09-20 06:24
皇馬備戰切爾西 :貝爾最後一舞? 小安出道之日?2024-09-20 06:18
You will love/hate Cards Against Humanity's new fortune cookies2024-09-20 05:56
圖赫爾 :這是最糟的失敗 與切爾西的標準相去甚遠2024-09-20 05:52
本澤馬 :飛一般的感覺 讓我們回主場見證最終結果2024-09-20 05:44
深度 :球員權力體係坑死曼聯 肖可拍電影毀滅紅魔2024-09-20 05:44
This 'sh*tpost' bot makes terrible memes so you don't have to2024-09-20 05:36
中超最早或將5月上旬開賽 賽區遴選下周初有望出結果2024-09-20 05:27
Tesla's rumored P100D could make Ludicrous mode even more Ludicrous2024-09-20 07:11
曝萊萬赴巴薩轉會費+薪水總價達1億歐 索要3年合同2024-09-20 07:06
歐冠賠率:次回合拜仁必逆襲 皇馬坐鎮伯納烏不穩2024-09-20 07:05
滄州雄獅助教: 我們有很多有潛力的球員 一些會成為未來國腳2024-09-20 06:57
Visualizing July's astounding global temperature records2024-09-20 06:55
曝上海海港仍在全力引進戴偉浚 張琳芃蔣光太也有望加盟2024-09-20 06:50
塞內加爾射手被曝接近上海海港 轉會推進過程非常順利2024-09-20 06:28
歐冠最佳進球:本澤馬哈弗茨掰頭 丁丁馬內團隊秀2024-09-20 06:23
Tourist survives for month in frozen New Zealand wilderness after partner dies2024-09-20 06:20
泰山海港敲定外援中鋒 中超“一擲千金”的時代徹底翻篇2024-09-20 06:04